34 Comments

I gave a terrifying level of thought to each vote.

Expand full comment
Aug 12, 2022Liked by Kelly Thompson

I want this to be the next wordle. I want to wake up and play this game every morning for just six weeks while I wait for water to heat up for coffee.

Expand full comment
Aug 12, 2022Liked by Kelly Thompson

Banshee is so fucked lol. His power only makes her stronger! He better have a shitload of pocket sand.

Expand full comment
founding
Aug 12, 2022Liked by Kelly Thompson

Magik v Jean Grey!! OMG, we need to see that. They’re both so kick ass

Expand full comment
Aug 12, 2022Liked by Kelly Thompson

I've been reading a lot of X-Factor recently (because i discovered how kickass Layla Miller is) so i suddenly have a lot more background on many of these characters than i did at the time of the last poll. Gotta go with Kitty Pryde for favorite and Strong Guy for least favorite. I just have never figured out a way to access/appreciate him.

Love this game!!

Expand full comment
founding
Aug 12, 2022Liked by Kelly Thompson

U r a far stronger person than I. I would’ve seen that Jean Magik match up n reshuffled that right up. So cruel to make me choose in that!

But I got to vote for Jubilee so YAY!

Expand full comment

much harder matchups this round. some real heartbreaking battles. like siren and madrox, with their history? she destroys him while he's crying.

mostly this makes me want to reread a lot of 90s x-men

Expand full comment
founding

I forgot to officially vote in this one... so that’s a bummer! But I would’ve voted for the winners in every fight except for the Bobby vs Kurt.

I would’ve gone with Iceman, but just marginally. I think he would’ve cooled the air off enough to slow Kurt down just enough to land a knockout blow.

Glad to see Gambit had a better matchup. My boy needs a bit of good news right now... right? Lol

Expand full comment
Aug 13, 2022Liked by Kelly Thompson

I did! They look rock hard! I love it 😀

Expand full comment
Aug 13, 2022Liked by Kelly Thompson

This has been great fun, both times! My most favorite is Emma, I think, or maybe Jean... someone female, I guess, I'm boring. Magik vs. Jean Grey would be a good read, I think. It's pretty easy to piss off Ilyana, so I can see this happening. Least favorite? I own these cards, and I don't remember who Cerise is.

Expand full comment
Aug 13, 2022Liked by Kelly Thompson

Thanks for the comp! Loved voting in this

Expand full comment
Aug 13, 2022·edited Aug 13, 2022Liked by Kelly Thompson

Can this be a monthly thing?! I absolutely fucking LOVE. IT!

My favourite character is defo Kwannon, I just love a psychic ex-ninja-assasin with a troubled past! 😍😭

Also now hunting out Wolverine & Jubilee on your recommendation as I've never really gotten on with young Jubes and I'd like to see what all the fuss is about 👍

Expand full comment
Aug 13, 2022Liked by Kelly Thompson

AHHH! Like last time, I just want to say this is a blast-and-a-half. TONS of great matchups in this reshuffle. I think there were even more great fights this time. SO. FUN.

I’ll answer some of the awesome questions you left for us:

What’s the best/closest match up here and why?

— That Domino v. Deadpool fight is a nail biter. After MUCH consideration, I gave it to Deadpool but that one was CLOSE.

— Also, Emma Frost v. Kitty Pryde and Psylocke v. Mystique both WRECKED me. (I picked Kitty and Mystique because I couldn’t really decide, so I went with my heart.)

Who is your favorite character from this group of 46? Least favorite? Do you know why for either?

— I love me some Nightcrawler but I have to say Kitty Pryde. I love that she could be perceived as passive or unassuming in personality and power-set but she actually has the heart of a lion and is an incredible leader and fighter.

Now, before I sign off, I want to make a case for Quicksilver beating Wolverine. I do not like Pietro (due to the fact that he’s an arrogant ass) but if he plays it smart, I think he wins this thing. He needs to overwhelm Logan with his speed, coming at him from different directions, taking his shots and getting out of range. I’m assuming Pietro has to knock Logan out or incapacitate him to win the fight, right? High speed whack on the head with a crowbar and then super-speedily dump him in the middle of a lake or an ocean while he’s stunned seems decisive to me. And pretty plausible. Is the majority of voters just assuming that Pietro *won’t* play it smart? (That’s pretty plausible, too.) Logan’s tough and heals quickly but if a knockout (or a lake-dump) counts as a win, I think Quicksliver can do it.

Expand full comment
founding
Aug 13, 2022Liked by Kelly Thompson

My question is about Jubilee. Are there any comics I should read where she’s a badass? Because I haven’t read it.

When I imagine Jubilee in a fight, I keep picturing a kid holding a sparkler or something. Maybe I’m wrong here, but I don’t think she ever wins any fight. Ever.

Expand full comment

Have you seen BULLET TRAIN? Brainless fun, but it makes a remarkably strong case against luck-based powers.

Expand full comment